The HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, costs $0.0214/GB while the 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... costs $0.0020/GB. 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... offers 91% better value per page as of July 2026. Both products are available on BuyPerUnit with prices from Amazon, Best Buy, and Newegg.
HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, vs 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... — Which Is Better Value?
Specification Comparison
| Spec | HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, | 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | HP | HP |
| Capacity | 20K pages | 20K pages |
| $/page | $0.0214 | $0.0020 |
| Price | $427.99 | $39.99 |
| Retailer | Newegg | Newegg |
| Category | Printer Ink & Toner | Printer Ink & Toner |
| Subcategory | toner | toner |
Price Across Retailers
Which Should You Buy?
Based on current pricing data, the 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... offers better value at $0.0020//page compared to the HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, at $0.0214//page — that's roughly 91% less per page.
The best deal for the 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... is $39.99 at Newegg, while the HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, starts at $427.99 at Newegg.
However, price per page isn't everything — consider factors like warranty, performance specs, brand reliability, and your specific capacity needs. Check each HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, and 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... product page for detailed specifications and price history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, or 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... a better deal?
As of July 2026, 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... offers better value at $0.0020//page compared to HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, at $0.0214//page. That is approximately 91% better value per page.
What is the price per GB of HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages,?
The HP 89Y Extra High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~20,000 pages, is currently priced at $0.0214/GB ($427.99 for 20K pages) at Newegg.
Where can I buy 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... for the cheapest price?
The cheapest price for the 1 Pack 45A Q5945A Compatible Toner Cartridge Fits for HP 45A Q5945A, Work with HP LaserJet 4200, 4200n,,4200tn, 4200dtn,4200dtns,... is $39.99 at Newegg, which works out to $0.0020/GB.