The HP 67XL is the better buy. It costs about $10 more than the standard HP 67, but it prints twice as many pages. That works out to 17% less per page. If you print more than a handful of times per month, the XL pays for itself quickly.
The only scenario where the standard HP 67 makes sense is if you print so rarely that ink dries out in the cartridge before you finish it.
HP 67 vs HP 67XL: The Numbers
| Cartridge | Page Yield | Typical Price | Price Per Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| HP 67 Black (Standard) | 120 pages | ~$15 | ~$0.125/page |
| HP 67XL Black | 240 pages | ~$25 | ~$0.104/page |
| HP 67 Tri-Color (Standard) | 100 pages | ~$18 | ~$0.180/page |
| HP 67XL Tri-Color | 200 pages | ~$28 | ~$0.140/page |
The XL black cartridge is 17% cheaper per page than the standard. The XL tri-color cartridge is 22% cheaper per page. In both cases, you pay 60 to 70 percent more upfront for 100 percent more pages.
Over a year of moderate printing — say, replacing cartridges every 2 months — the XL saves roughly $15 to $25 on black ink alone. Add color printing and the savings double.
Which Printers Use HP 67?
The HP 67 / 67XL cartridge family is used in a wide range of HP's consumer inkjet printers:
- HP DeskJet: 1255, 2700 series, 2752e, 2755e, 4100 series, 4155e
- HP ENVY: 6000 series, 6020e, 6055e, 6400 series, 6455e
- HP ENVY Inspire: 7200 series, 7900 series
- HP AMP: 100
If you own any of these printers, the HP 67 and 67XL are your cartridge options. Check your printer's documentation or the label inside the cartridge access door to confirm.
Multi-Pack Savings
HP sells the 67XL in twin-packs and combo packs (black + tri-color). These offer an additional 10 to 15 percent savings per cartridge compared to buying singles.
| Pack | Typical Price | Per Cartridge | Savings vs Singles |
|---|---|---|---|
| HP 67XL Black (single) | ~$25 | $25.00 | — |
| HP 67XL Black (twin-pack) | ~$44 | $22.00 | 12% |
| HP 67XL Black + Tri-Color Combo | ~$48 | $24.00 each | 6% |
If you know you will go through multiple cartridges — and you will — buying the twin-pack is the best value within the OEM HP lineup. The combo pack is convenient but offers smaller per-unit savings.
OEM vs Compatible HP 67XL
The HP 67XL is one of the most widely cloned cartridges on the market. Compatible versions are available from dozens of third-party manufacturers on Amazon and other retailers, typically priced at $10 to $15 for a single XL black cartridge — a 40 to 60 percent discount compared to HP's OEM version.
| Version | Typical Price (XL Black) | Price Per Page |
|---|---|---|
| OEM HP 67XL | ~$25 | ~$0.104/page |
| Compatible HP 67XL | ~$12 | ~$0.050/page |
That is a dramatic difference. The compatible version cuts the per-page cost roughly in half. For document printing — text, charts, forms — the quality is indistinguishable from OEM. Your printer warranty is protected by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act regardless of which cartridge you use. See our full OEM vs compatible breakdown for details.
The One Reason to Buy Standard
Ink cartridges can dry out. If you print once a month or less, you might not finish an XL cartridge before the ink starts to dry and clog the printhead. In this scenario, the standard HP 67 makes more sense — not because it is cheaper per page (it is not), but because you will actually use the ink before it goes bad.
If you print a few times a month or more, this is not a concern. The XL cartridge will be empty long before the ink has a chance to dry.
The Bottom Line
Buy the HP 67XL. It costs a few dollars more but delivers twice the pages at 17% less per page. If you print regularly, buy it in twin-packs for an additional 12% savings. And if you want the deepest discount, compatible HP 67XL cartridges cut the per-page cost in half with no meaningful quality trade-off for document printing.
Compare All HP Ink by Price Per Page →