Brother toner provides a significantly lower cost per page than HP tracked cartridges. SuppliesMAX Brother HL-2460 jumbo toner yields 15,000 pages at $78.99, costing $0.005266 per page. HP's tracked TCT 67XL Tri-Color High Yield ink cartridge costs $0.23495 per page. Buyers save $0.229684 per page by choosing Brother.
Price Per Page Breakdown
Three tracked listings from our printer-ink rankings dictate the current market landscape, sorted strictly by cost per page:
- SuppliesMAX Brother HL-2460 Jumbo Toner — 15,000 pages at $78.99 = $0.005266/page (newegg)
- SuppliesMAX Brother DCP-L2500 Toner — 2,600 pages at $17.99 = $0.006919/page (newegg)
Brother holds every sub-cent-per-page position. HP's cheapest tracked listing costs $0.23495/page — $0.229684 more per page than Brother's cheapest option. Even Brother's most expensive tracked toner at $0.006919/page costs less than a single penny, while HP's tracked cartridge sits much higher.
Same Capacity, Same Tier?
When evaluating the keyword "hp vs brother toner cost per page which is cheaper", you have to look at the underlying print technologies and drum costs of HP LaserJet vs Brother laser printers. Both brands utilize electrostatic laser printing, but they handle consumables differently.
Brother laser printers typically use a two-cartridge system: a toner cartridge and a separate drum unit. While the drum unit is an occasional replacement cost, it allows the toner cartridge itself to be manufactured and sold much cheaper. HP LaserJet printers traditionally use a combined cartridge where the toner and the drum are integrated into a single unit. Because the drum is replaced every time you buy toner, HP's cartridges inherently cost more to produce, driving up the cost per page.
Regarding page yields, Brother's high-yield and jumbo toner models easily scale up to 6,000 or even 15,000 pages, heavily diluting the purchase price. HP's standard and high-yield monochrome LaserJet toners usually cap out around 3,000 to 4,000 pages for standard office models, keeping their floor cost per page significantly higher.
The cost-per-page gap between HP and Brother here is not just about brand pricing — it is about consumable architecture. Brother's separation of the drum unit allows their toner yields to stretch much further for a lower purchase price.
What the Extra Cost Buys You
For Brother, the lower per-page cost comes with toner compatible with HL-2460, DCP-L2500, HL-L5215, HL-L6310, MFC-L5710, and MFC-L6915DW printers, among others. Page yields range from 2,600 to 15,000 pages across the tracked listings. The SuppliesMAX jumbo toner (TN-9500J) targets the HL-2460 and HL-2460N specifically.
When Each Makes Sense
- Choose Brother toner if you want the lowest cost per page and have a compatible Brother laser printer. The SuppliesMAX jumbo toner delivers 15,000 pages at $0.005266/page.
- Choose HP toner if you operate an HP printer and prefer the convenience of an all-in-one cartridge that replaces the drum every cycle. Alternatively, explore broader brand comparisons to see if another HP cartridge offers better yield.
Verdict
Brother wins on cost per page at $0.005266/page versus HP's $0.23495/page. Prices verified as of 2026-08-03 — check the live table above for current figures.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper per page, HP or Brother toner?
Brother. The SuppliesMAX jumbo toner for the Brother HL-2460 costs $0.005266/page (15,000 pages at $78.99). HP's cheapest tracked listing costs $0.23495/page.
How much does Brother toner cost per page?
Across tracked listings, Brother toner ranges from $0.005266/page (SuppliesMAX 15,000-page jumbo at $78.99) to $0.006919/page (SuppliesMAX 2,600-page toner at $17.99). Both sit well under one cent per page.
Why is HP toner more expensive than Brother toner per page?
HP LaserJet cartridges typically use a combined design that includes the drum unit inside the toner cartridge, raising the manufacturing cost. Brother separates the drum unit from the toner, allowing the toner itself to be cheaper and yield significantly more pages (up to 15,000). See our cost-per-page methodology for the math behind these figures.
Does a higher page yield lower cost per page?
Yes. The SuppliesMAX Brother DCP-L2500 toner costs $17.99 for 2,600 pages ($0.006919/page). Stepping up to the 15,000-page jumbo at $78.99 drops the cost to $0.005266/page.