The True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother costs $0.0042/GB while the True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P costs $0.0062/GB. True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother offers 33% better value per page as of August 2026. Both products are available on BuyPerUnit with prices from Amazon, Best Buy, and Newegg.
True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother vs True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P — Which Is Better Value?
Prices refresh twice daily; the final price appears at the retailer's checkout. We may earn a commission from retailer links, at no cost to you; it never affects rankings.
Specification Comparison
| Spec | True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother | True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | True | HP |
| Capacity | 6.5K pages | 6.5K pages |
| $/page | $0.0042 | $0.0062 |
| Price | $26.99 | $39.99 |
| Retailer | Newegg | Newegg |
| Category | Printer Ink & Toner | Printer Ink & Toner |
| Subcategory | toner | toner |
Price Across Retailers
True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother
True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P
Which Should You Buy?
Based on current pricing data, the True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother offers better value at $0.0042//page compared to the True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P at $0.0062//page — that's roughly 33% less per page.
The best deal for the True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother is $26.99 at Newegg, while the True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P starts at $39.99 at Newegg.
However, price per page isn't everything — consider factors like warranty, performance specs, brand reliability, and your specific capacity needs. Check each True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother and True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P product page for detailed specifications and price history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother or True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P a better deal?
As of August 2026, True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother offers better value at $0.0042//page compared to True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P at $0.0062//page. That is approximately 33% better value per page.
What is the price per GB of True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother?
The True Color Toner TN436 Magenta Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for Brother TN436M Magenta High Yield Works With Brother is currently priced at $0.0042/GB ($26.99 for 6.5K pages) at Newegg.
Where can I buy True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P for the cheapest price?
The cheapest price for the True Color Toner 51A Toner Cartridge - Premium Compatible Replacement for HP 51A Q7551A Black Works With HP LaserJet P3005 P3005D P3005X P is $39.99 at Newegg, which works out to $0.0062/GB.