HP 63XL cartridges win on cost per page. The cheapest tracked HP 63XL compatible (Paeolos, 2-pack on Amazon) runs $0.021642 per page versus $0.042714 per page for the cheapest HP 67XL compatible (TECKKIN, 2-pack on Amazon) — a difference of $0.0211 per page. Prices observed July 31, 2026.
The Short Answer
HP 63XL wins. The cheapest tracked HP 63XL compatible cartridge (Paeolos, 2-pack at Amazon) costs $0.021642 per page. The cheapest tracked HP 67XL compatible (TECKKIN, 2-pack at Amazon) costs $0.042714 per page. That is $0.0211 more per page for the 67XL.
The gap holds across brands. Every tracked HP 67XL compatible cartridge costs more per page than the Paeolos 63XL at the floor. Even the second-cheapest 63XL option (Eudul at $0.0388/page) undercuts the cheapest 67XL.
Price Per Page Breakdown
Here are the tracked floors for each cartridge family, computed using our price-per-unit methodology:
HP 63XL compatible cartridges (sorted by cost per page):
| Brand | Price | Retailer | Cost/Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paeolos | $25.97 | Amazon | $0.021642 |
| Eudul | $29.10 | Amazon | $0.0388 |
| Limeink | $28.28 | Amazon | $0.047133 |
| HP (OEM) | $89.99 | Newegg | $0.128557 |
| HP (OEM) | $149.99 | Newegg | $0.214271 |
HP 67XL compatible cartridges (sorted by cost per page):
| Brand | Price | Retailer | Cost/Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| TECKKIN | $29.90 | Amazon | $0.042714 |
| AvantInk | $32.98 | Amazon | $0.043973 |
| INKCLOUD | $35.98 | Amazon | $0.047973 |
| InkID | $34.98 | Amazon | $0.049971 |
| Ankink | $38.69 | Amazon | $0.085978 |
The OEM HP-branded 63XL cartridges at Newegg ($89.99 and $149.99) deliver cost-per-page figures of $0.128557 and $0.214271 respectively — well above every third-party option tracked. That price gap is not a premium for better ink. It is the cost of buying the HP brand name on the box.
Same Capacity, Same Tier?
Both cartridge families carry the "XL" high-yield designation, but they are not interchangeable. The HP 63XL fits older HP printer models:
- HP Envy 4520, 4512, 4510
- HP OfficeJet 4650, 5255, 3830, 5200
- HP DeskJet 3630, 2132, 1112
The HP 67XL fits newer HP printer models:
- HP DeskJet 2855e, 2800e, 2755e, 4255e, 4155e
- HP Envy 6055e, 6000, 6455e
Your printer dictates which cartridge you need. The cost-per-page comparison matters most if you are deciding which printer to buy — not which cartridge to put in a printer you already own.
Manufacturer-rated page yields for the HP 63XL are commonly listed at 480 pages (black) and 330 pages (color). The HP 67XL provides even more pages than the 63XL.
What the Extra Cost Buys You
Nothing measurable in ink quality or page yield. The higher cost per page of HP 67XL cartridges reflects a younger third-party market, not superior performance. Both cartridge families are 2-pack black/color combos from compatible-ink manufacturers.
The 63XL compatible market has five tracked brands (Paeolos, Eudul, Limeink, plus OEM HP at two price points). The 67XL compatible market also has five tracked brands (TECKKIN, AvantInk, INKCLOUD, InkID, Ankink). But the 63XL ecosystem has existed longer, giving remanufacturers more time to drive floor prices down — Paeolos sits at $25.97, which is $3.93 below the cheapest 67XL option at $29.90.
If you want a fundamentally lower cost per page, neither cartridge family is the answer. Refillable ink tank systems using bottles from brands tracked in our database (Faslvink, OKGO!INK, OFCINK) start at $0.0006 per page — roughly 36 times cheaper than the Paeolos 63XL floor.
When Each Makes Sense
-
Choose HP 63XL if your printer uses it (Envy 4520, OfficeJet 4650, DeskJet 3630, and related models). The Paeolos 2-pack at $25.97 delivers the lowest tracked cost per page in this comparison at $0.021642/page. If you are shopping for a used printer and choosing between a 63XL-compatible and a 67XL-compatible model, the 63XL printer will cost less to operate over time.
-
Choose HP 67XL if your printer requires it (DeskJet 2800e series, Envy 6000 series). The TECKKIN 2-pack at $29.90 is your floor at $0.042714/page. You cannot substitute a 63XL cartridge in these printers. For more on this cartridge family, see our HP 67 vs 67XL breakdown.
Verdict
HP 63XL wins on cost per page at $0.021642/page (Paeolos) versus $0.042714/page (TECKKIN) for the HP 67XL. The 63XL's more mature third-party ecosystem delivers a lower floor price. But cartridge choice is dictated by printer model — if your printer takes 67XL, the TECKKIN 2-pack at Amazon is your best tracked option at $29.90 as of July 31, 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which printer cartridge is cheaper per page: HP 67XL or HP 63XL?
HP 63XL is cheaper. The lowest tracked cost per page is $0.021642 (Paeolos 63XL, 2-pack at $25.97 on Amazon) versus $0.042714 (TECKKIN 67XL, 2-pack at $29.90 on Amazon). That is $0.0211 less per page for the 63XL.
What is the cost per page of an HP 63XL ink cartridge?
Tracked cost per page ranges from $0.021642 (Paeolos, $25.97 at Amazon) to $0.214271 (HP OEM, $149.99 at Newegg) across five tracked listings. The floor is $0.021642 per page.
How much does it cost per page to print with an HP 67XL cartridge?
Tracked cost per page ranges from $0.042714 (TECKKIN, $29.90 at Amazon) to $0.085978 (Ankink, $38.69 at Amazon) across five tracked listings. The floor is $0.042714 per page.
Does the HP 67XL have a higher page yield than the HP 63XL?
HP 63XL cartridges are commonly rated at 480 pages (black) and 330 pages (color) per manufacturer specifications. The HP 67XL provides even more pages than the 63XL. The cost-per-page figures in this comparison are derived from tracked retail prices and official manufacturer yield data.