HP 910XL vs HP 910: Cost Per Page Compared (825 vs 300)
The HP 910XL wins on cost per page — with one caveat. Our live data tracks the 910XL Black (3YL65AN) at $56.89 on Amazon: $56.89 ÷ 825 rated pages = $0.069 per page. The standard HP 910 has no in-stock listing in our comparison data as of August 24, 2026. The deciding math: the XL prints 825 ÷ 300 = 2.75× the pages, so it wins per page whenever it sells for under 2.75× the 910's price.
The Short Answer
The HP 910XL takes this matchup on the tracked numbers, and the arithmetic backs it up even with the missing side. Our live printer-ink rankings show the HP 910XL Black High-Yield (3YL65AN) in stock at Amazon for $56.89 — $56.89 ÷ 825 rated pages = $0.068958 per page. That figure is a floor (the cheapest in-stock 910XL listing we track), not an average. The standard-yield HP 910 has no tracked listing on its side of this comparison as of August 24, 2026, so there is no live per-page number to set beside it. The yield ratings still decide the structure: 825 ÷ 300 = 2.75× more pages per cartridge, which means the 910XL costs less per page any time it sells for less than 2.75× the standard 910's price.
Price Per Page Breakdown
| Cartridge | Live price | Rated pages | Cost per page | Retailer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP 910XL Black (3YL65AN) | $56.89 | 825 | $56.89 ÷ 825 = $0.068958 | Amazon |
| HP 910 Black (standard) | No tracked listing | 300 | — | — |
One wrinkle: HP's own store lists the 910XL black yield at approximately 720 pages, not the 825 our listing data carries. Same cartridge, same $56.89 — $56.89 ÷ 720 = $0.079 per page, a $0.010-per-page swing depending on whose rating you use. Color cartridges split the same way: 315 rated pages for the standard 910 color, 825 for the 910XL color. Floors, averages, and per-unit rankings are computed identically across every category we track — the details are in our methodology.
At Amazon's tracked $56.89, the 910XL beats the standard 910 on cost per page whenever the 910 is priced above $56.89 × 300 ÷ 825 = $20.69. Using HP's 720-page rating instead, the crossover rises to $56.89 × 300 ÷ 720 = $23.70.
Same Capacity, Same Tier?
Not the same capacity — that is the entire comparison. The 910 and 910XL are the standard- and high-yield tiers of the same cartridge line: the tracked 910XL listing names OfficeJet 8010, 8020 Series, OfficeJet Pro 8020, and 8030 Series compatibility, and the 3YL65AN is eligible for HP's Instant Ink program. Same printers, same black ink slot, 300 vs 825 rated pages. If you want the same standard-vs-XL math run on another HP line, our HP 952 vs 952XL cost-per-page guide covers it.
What the Extra Cost Buys You
The 910XL's higher shelf price buys rated capacity and nothing else measurable here: 825 pages vs 300 — 2.75× as many prints between swaps — plus Instant Ink eligibility on the tracked listing. HP's cartridge guide also lists a 916XL extra-high-yield black rated at 1,500 pages; we track no live 916XL price, so no verified per-page number for it exists in our data. Compatibility and form factor do not change between the 910 and 910XL tiers.
When Each Makes Sense
- Choose the HP 910XL if the standard 910 is listed above $20.69 where you shop — at $56.89 for 825 rated pages ($0.069/page), every page past the crossover is money kept.
- Choose the HP 910 if your upfront budget is under the 910XL's $56.89 and you will not finish 825 pages — a 300-page cartridge you actually empty beats a high-yield cartridge that sits half-used.
Verdict
Winner: the HP 910XL, at a tracked $0.068958 per page — $56.89 at Amazon, 825 rated pages, price-checked August 24, 2026. The standard 910 has no live listing on its side of this comparison, so treat any per-page claim for it as unverified until you check the current price; the XL wins whenever the 910 sits above $20.69. For context on where OEM cartridge pricing sits relative to the cheapest in-stock listings in our printer-ink rankings: those are refill bottles for tank printers — Faslvink's 30,000-page set at $19.99, which is $19.99 ÷ 30,000 = $0.00067 per page — a different printing model entirely, covered in our cheapest ink per page comparison. To see whether the 910XL floor has moved, check the live listing →.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the HP 910XL really cheaper per page than the HP 910?
It is whenever the price ratio holds: 825 ÷ 300 = 2.75, so the 910XL wins per page at any price under 2.75× the 910's. At the tracked $56.89 Amazon listing, that crossover is $20.69. With no live 910 listing as of August 24, 2026, verify the 910's current price before assuming the XL wins today.
How many pages does the HP 910XL print vs the HP 910?
Rated black yields: 825 pages for the 910XL vs 300 for the standard 910 — though HP's own store lists the 910XL black at approximately 720 pages. Color yields: 825 pages (910XL) vs 315 pages (910).
What's the maximum I should pay for an HP 910XL to keep the per-page win?
2.75× whatever the standard 910 costs, or 2.4× if you use HP's 720-page rating (720 ÷ 300 = 2.4). Example: if the 910 is listed at $20, the 910XL wins below $20 × 2.75 = $55 on the 825-page rating, or below $20 × 2.4 = $48 on the 720-page rating.
Are compatible HP 910XL cartridges cheaper per page?
We track no HP 910XL compatible listings right now, so there is no verified number to quote. The cheapest in-stock listings in our printer-ink data are refill bottles for Epson tank printers — for example, Faslvink's 30,000-page set at $19.99 ($19.99 ÷ 30,000 = $0.00067/page) — which is different hardware, not a drop-in 910XL substitute.