The Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle costs $0.0025/GB while the 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn costs $0.1250/GB. Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle offers 98% better value per page as of August 2026. Both products are available on BuyPerUnit with prices from Amazon, Best Buy, and Newegg.
Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle vs 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn — Which Is Better Value?
Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle
Prices refresh twice daily; the final price appears at the retailer's checkout. We may earn a commission from retailer links, at no cost to you; it never affects rankings.
Specification Comparison
| Spec | Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle | 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Brother | HP |
| Capacity | 5K pages | 3K pages |
| $/page | $0.0025 | $0.1250 |
| Price | $12.29 | $374.99 |
| Retailer | Best Buy | Newegg |
| Category | Printer Ink & Toner | Printer Ink & Toner |
| Subcategory | cartridge | toner |
Price Across Retailers
Which Should You Buy?
Based on current pricing data, the Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle offers better value at $0.0025//page compared to the 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn at $0.1250//page — that's roughly 98% less per page.
The best deal for the Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle is $12.29 at Best Buy, while the 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn starts at $374.99 at Newegg.
However, price per page isn't everything — consider factors like warranty, performance specs, brand reliability, and your specific capacity needs. Check each Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle and 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn product page for detailed specifications and price history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle or 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn a better deal?
As of August 2026, Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle offers better value at $0.0025//page compared to 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn at $0.1250//page. That is approximately 98% better value per page.
What is the price per GB of Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle?
The Brother - Genuine BTD180Y High-Yield Yellow Ink Bottle is currently priced at $0.0025/GB ($12.29 for 5K pages) at Best Buy.
Where can I buy 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn for the cheapest price?
The cheapest price for the 58A Black Toner Cartridge with Chip Compatible with HP 58A CF258A 58X CF258X Replacement for HP Color Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw M404n M428fdn is $374.99 at Newegg, which works out to $0.1250/GB.